Review: BrisketTown (Delaney BBQ)

359 Bedford Ave
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY

Shifting off of a project in Portland to one in New York, BrisketTown was the first restaurant I had in my sights to write about on the blog. You see I, like most food enthusiasts in Texas, have been watching Daniel Delaney with a somewhat curious eye. Reading reports about the brisket coming out of BrisketLab, a pop-up type restaurant that allowed Delaney to hone his smoking his skills before opening a brick and mortar, I was excited to see for myself how his skills developed and how his brisket stacks up to my favorites. Take a second to check out Daniel Vaughn’s write up on TM Daily Post about BrisketLab here, it’s definitely worth your time.

Plugging in the address for BrisketTown as a co-worker and I left our hotel on a Wednesday, the GPS on my phone showed an hour and a half drive. I sheepishly assured him that the meal would be worth the drive. I didn’t actually know whether it would be, I’m just generally non-confrontational.

Pulling up to the entrance, was a bit confusing. There’s no sign outside, you kind of have to figure out where it is for yourself. I actually saw Delaney standing outside, so that was a good giveaway as to the location. We lucked out and found street parking just a few cars down from the entrance. I’m not sure how hard finding a parking in Williamsbug normally is.

Finally inside the restaurant, we strolled up to the counter (set up in traditional Texas BBQ meat market style) and ordered our meal.

My order was a pound of brisket, a half pound of ribs, some potato salad and a Mexican coke. Squatting into our table, I immediately tore into the brisket. A place that calls itself BrisketTown needs to bring the goods.

“Damn.” That was my first reaction. Immediately followed by a smirk and a quiet laugh. Looking at my colleague (who lives in Oregon and has apparently never had real BBQ), he had the same grin on his face. Without saying anything more to each other, we both nodded and returned to our attention to our plates.

The brisket has all the indicators of a well seasoned pitmaster. The salt to pepper ratio on the bark was spot on. The smoke ring was beautiful and thick. And the fat was perfectly rendered, in both the lean and fatty cuts, indicative of a patient approach to smoking the meat – the dude obviously found the sweet spot for temperature & time during BrisketLab.

The ribs were less Impressive. They were a bit chewy and were somewhat lacking in smokiness. They weren’t bad mind you, but definitely not in the same league as the brisket.  The potato salad was fine, it didn’t leave a lasting impression either way. I wasn’t huge on the other side options, but that is just personal preference. I generally like more low brow selections like mac & cheese or fried okra when I’m eating BBQ.

To say I was impressed with BrisketTown is a vast understatement. I’ve been so accustomed to being disappointed in BBQ joints that I try during my travels (see Smoque) that it was beyond refreshing to see someone doing brisket right. The ribs weren’t quite there yet, but I’m confident Delaney will make tweaks to bring them up to par.

The brisket here is better than any brisket I’ve ever had outside of Texas, and it holds up just fine against the greats inside of my fair state. It is deserving of a 5 star rating by itself.

RATING: *****

BrisketTown on Urbanspoon